SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Halos Heaven

EDDIE BANE TERMINATED Angels 2010 Top Ten #4

Someone had to take the fall for the first losing season since 2003 and that man would be Eddie Bane. The Angels fired their scouting director with a few days left in the season. Was it the underwhelming 2010 draft? Was it the failure of Brandon Wood? Was it the end of an appetite for high-risk, high-reward high-schoolers? Was it the other shoe dropping from the Clay Daniels escapade of 2009, an underpublicized scandal of allegations of skimming by team representatives in Latin America? Was it something else? Was it all of the above?

While the taint of insubordination befouled his predecessor Donny Rowland, a man who had mutinied against Bill Stoneman only to be shown the door, Eddie Bane's departure remains a fog of conjecture amidst swirling speculation... He drafted Jered Weaver and signed Kendry Morales. But after the failure of a superstar to develop out of Kotchman, McPherson and then Wood ... well, major league scout Dale Sutherland and trainer Ned Bergert were also shown the door, so the confluence of bad decisions coming home to roost in a lousy season that had no backup plan led to Eddie Bane's contract unrenewed. He latched on with Detroit in less than a month. The man who signed Mike Trout is a Tiger and we're all just left wondering whether this means that college graduates are now welcome in Anaheim's June draft.

0 recs  |  20 comments

Comments

Not sure why Bane was pointed towards the exit

but one thing remains clear – some of the players drafted by his advice did not pan out. It happens. When a team is NOT doing well, it is seem as another symptom of the disease. On the other hand, when a successful team stumbles, someone will be blamed. I guess Bane drew the short straw among the possible scapegoat candidates available to the front office.

Glad he landed on “his feet” wit the Tigers. Not sure what future drafts will look like. I guess we have to be patient and see.

What I'm unfamiliar with is

What type of draft picks more oftenly become regulars or stars?
Is it polished college players or those high school players with lots of potential?

Good question.

I would not know even where to look for that kind of breakdown. It would be an interesting question to get an answer to, though.

Seems to vary somewhat by player position.

That is, after it varies most by round taken. A first round draft pick is obviously far more likely to achieve success than a 20th round pick – independent of education levels. (Duh!)

By happenstance, there’s a fresh 2-part article up on just this topic over at MLB Bonus Baby, an SBNation blog.

Analyzing the MLB Draft, Part 1
and
Draft Analysis, Part II

Contrasts the “successes” of 4-year college, Juco and high school draftees by defensive position. I’m not enamored with the methodology used but the data set is interesting.

Thanks!

I’ll have to check those links out tonight after work.

While reading this, the word "scapegoat" kept entering my mind.
Can we have Tampa Bay's scouting director?
seriously!

I was gonna say the same thing…
Who is he? I know a simple google search would probably present an answer but I just don’t have the time to search right now..

R.J. Harrison
Wish we could get either Billy Beane or Theo Epstein as our GM also
Pass on Beane

I don’t he is temperamentally suited for an organization like ours. (i.e., one that already has an organizational culture, and a budget.)

he wasn't exactly fired

his contract was up and they didn’t renew it

It's the polite way to fire someone.
Ah, so the "let him down easy" huh?

Boy, that seems sooooo much more dignified (rolls eyes sarcastically).

Did they tell him that they "just want to be friends," too?
hmmm. That phrase sounds a little too familiar to me
Unfortunatel, I could not forget it if I tried.

And I have, trust me I have.

do you guys remember the headline "Ned Bergert Shitcanned"

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Halos Heaven to post a comment.