SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Halos Heaven

10/31 Postseason Review: Forbidden Fruit

Giants 4, Rangers 0 (San Francisco leads series 3-1)

The thrill of victory is always accompanied by the agony of defeat. If you want to be a baseball fan in October, you have to be willing to take on a large risk of disappointment in exchange for the small chance of winning it all. The expectation grows with each step closer, but so does the bitterness of possible failure.

Star-divide

So I'll ask a question. Which is worse: getting blasted in the division series and sent home in the first week, or coming oh-so-close to grasping the ultimate and then blowing it? One of these two teams will experience the latter. If the Giants lose, they'll have choked away another World Series in spectacular fashion. If the Rangers lose, they'll have beaten the Rays and Yankees, probably the best two teams in baseball, only to founder against the mediocre Giants.

My vote would go with coming close and falling short. If you get destroyed immediately, it feels like you never belonged in the postseason. But if the season ends in anticlimax, you'll have years to curse that one bad break that just didn't go your way. Donnie Moore and Dave Henderson anyone? And that didn't even happen in the World Series. Technically, the home run Brian Fuentes coughed up to Alex Rodriguez in Game 2 of the 2009 ALCS was just as decisive, but it certainly doesn't feel that way, does it?

Poll
Which is more disappointing for fans?
Getting blown out in three straight division series games.
172 votes
Losing Game 7 of the World Series in extra innings.
162 votes

334 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  20 comments

Comments

Got to be in the dance contest to win it..........

…………so there’s my vote.

the fans in that pic are wearing more red than blue

wtf?

They have no idea what their team color is
As a Twins fan

Getting swept, again, by the hated yanquis in the ALDS is the epitome of disappointment, but it’s better to be in the playoffs and lose than never to have had the chance at all.

Getting swept in the division series for sure

Losing game 7 of the World Series would suck, but it also means you ruined at least two other teams’ October dreams.

Like always, it’s about street cred.

As a fan
probably the 2nd scenario. I wouldn’t want to be a Giants fan in 2002 at Game 6 of the WS in the 7th inning.

1st choice would be the worst.

1st choice would say to me that my team was on some fluke run to get to where they got, and their luck ran out revealing them to be the pretenders that they are. Caught pantless in public, stuck with some incredibly stupid antler-claw rally idiocy stitched to my cap, and utterly humiliated.

2nd choice would say to me that my team was just as good, just as deserving, but the breaks BARELY went the other way. I could go to my grave deluding myself that my team had every right to lay honorary claim to that missed title.

That sums it up pretty well.

sure looks like they are thinking about their dream season

doesn’t it?

I thought our 2007 ALDS with the Roid Sox was just dreamy too...
not sure if anyone who comes here

follows professional surfing at all. but I just found out that Andy Irons passed away today from Dengue fever, which he got during the last contest in Portugal. he was found dead in a hotel room in Dallas on a layover on his way home.

for those that don’t know, Irons won 3 world titles earlier this decade (2002-2004), and was seen as the only real legitimate competition Kelly Slater ever had. after Slater retired, Irons won 2 straight world titles, which got people talking about him possibly being better than Slater. Slater came back the following year, and the world title race came down to the final heat in the final contest of the year at Pipeline, and Irons won it. Slater then went on to win a few more world titles, and is a shoe-in for his 10th this year.

Irons was 32 years old and born and raised in Kauai. his wife was pregant with (I think) their 2nd child.

very sad day for the surfing world

RIP AI

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Halos Heaven to post a comment.