SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Halos Heaven

10/30 Postseaon Review: Who Needs College?

Rangers 4, Giants 2 (San Francisco leads series 2-1)

Well, that was a little more...conventional. Not that there wasn't some weirdness, like all runs scoring via home runs. Or how about this one: Vladimir Guerrero, Bengie Molina, and Jeff Francoeur drawing four unintentional walks in the same game. That trifecta has about a 5% career walk rate, so the chance of four walks in ten plate appearances is less than 0.1%. So there's your bizarreness for the evening. Except that it's really not that bizarre, because Jonathan Sanchez walks everybody.

I have to confess that I'm really smitten by this Mitch Moreland guy. You may otherwise know him as the guy who hit two home runs off of Jered Weaver in his last start of the season. A 17th round pick out of Mississippi State in 2007, now he's turning heads in the World Series. I don't think he's just having a good day, either. He looks like he knows what he's doing at the plate. He reminds me of maybe the young Sean Casey: not a big star, but just solid in every department.

Star-divide

So now I'm wondering, why can't the Angels ever seem to dig up position players like this guy? Yeah, yeah, it's all Eddie Bane's fault, or whatever. Look, I won't pretend I know how the front office works. But if you made me guess, I would say that drafting all these athletic kids right out of high school has something to do with it. They can run, they can jump, they can put a ball in play, but can they actually hit? Who knows, they're 17 years old!

Obviously you can't expect to find a Sean Casey in the 17th round very often. However, it seems the Angels have strongly disfavored college hitters in the draft. They haven't selected a position player out of college in any of the first four rounds since 2001 (I did a brief breakdown awhile ago). I read an interview with Bane a few years ago where he explained this along the lines of "well, we're never going to draft very high in the order, so we'd rather go for exciting high-schoolers than middle-class collegians."

Sure, that's true for the first round pick, but what about the second round? Or the third? And so on. The Angels' system could use a few more middle-class hitters with polish and experience. Some of their more interesting guys right now are later-round college picks (although they might just look good against less experienced competition). Too bad Eddie won't be around to enjoy drafting a little higher in the order next June. I can't help but think he should reap the benefit of this situation he probably had a hand in creating.

Poll
Ken Rosenthal is so short...
He hears his clubhouse rumors from the cockroaches.
18 votes
Fox bought an electron microscope just for his TV appearances.
10 votes
Ron Washington almost snorted him.
119 votes

147 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  9 comments

Comments

Casey Kotchman was supposed to be exactly what you wanted, only better

He just peaked at age 24, bizarrely.

There was a good piece about Moreland in the NYT today — dude was a great pitcher in college, and the Rangers had him throwing some relief in between 1B starts in the minors, until his hitting got too good.

Kotchman did have the skill set I'm talking about

Namely low K/BB and tons of extra-base hits, but as you said, he was supposed to be even better. He was supposed to be Keith Hernandez. I didn’t bring him up because he was expected to be a star from the time he turned 20.

My unscientific opinion is that these middle-class hitters, who are just a little bit better than average at everything, tend to get drafted out of college more often than high school. Jeff DaVanon is maybe the most recent example to come through the Angels system. Even then, Sandy Alderson was the guy who actually drafted him out of college, and the Angels only got him in the Randy Velarde deal.

DaVanon had some really tough luck, I think. If I remember correctly, he got injured for like 18 months when he was just about ready to break in. After that, he rode the bus for a couple years and then got forced into a fourth-outfielder role by Anderson, Erstad, and Salmon. Still, he was rock solid for a couple of seasons before Stoneman dropped him like an infield popup when his batting average slipped.

bane mayb not b able to enjoy

Picking high in the draft w. The angels next june… But that’s not to say he not going to b doing that a lot w. His new team! :\ … Tell saundo’ I said hi

Brilliant write-up and poll in all aspects

I agree with everything you said.

I can usually agree with everrything you say but I can't get my head that far up my ass on certain things.
Constipation is a bitch isn't it?
The Ron Washington coke jokes

never get old.

Lay off of Robothol.

From the looks of his new attire, he must have just become a part of the Nation of Islam.

he's so short...

… You can see his feet in his drivers license photo.

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Halos Heaven to post a comment.