SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Halos Heaven

Lunch Thread: Matt Holliday or Roy Halladay

Lunch Thread... discuss these two...

Poll
Which of these insane trades do you like better?
Wood and Saunders to Toronto for Roy Halladay and Vernon Wells, then we flip Wells and Matthews to the Giants for Zito
160 votes
Wood, Kendrick, Walden and Conger to Oakland for Matt Holliday and Mark Ellis
29 votes
I prefer MY insane trade proposal, check the comments...
58 votes

247 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  32 comments

Comments

Let's just trade

Matthews for Zito straight up.

The Giants get out of paying Zito, and we get rid of Matthews.

I’d be willing to take the chance that Butcher could straighten Zito out.

I say we trade K-Rod for whoever we want

They said that he was on the Angels during the AllStarGame, and that’s national T.V.

Also I was thinking that we could say Junior was GA, but Atlanta is in the NL East. So we might not get away with that one.

Anyone who takes that Wells contract is insane.

2010: $12.5 million
2011: $23 million
2012: $21 million
2013: $21 million
2014: $21 million

Good God

Who the Hell would give a contract like THAT to a player like Wells?! He was never THAT great

Bill Stoneman would
According to Cot's,

he’s also due an unpaid portion of his signing bonus of $8.5m on March 1, 2010. That would mean a real 2010 expenditure of $21m. Insane.

Lets trade Matt Brown, GMJ, and Izturis FOR...................

ADRIAN GONZALEZ!!!!!

Figg – 3B
Abreu – DH
Hunter – CF (EVANS for now at the bottom of the lineup)
Gonzales – 1B
Rivera – LF
Morales – RF
Napoli – C
Wood – SS
Aybar – 2B

We'll probably have to add Sean Rodriguez which is aight if he starts over there.
We'd also have to send along some of Arte's cash for the Padres to take GMJ

That said, I don’t think they’d be willing to trade Gonzalez.

I read he was available.......maybe i saw wrong but that would be the trade or NO trade at all.

I dont want to get rid of Sheriff Woody……….then who would warn us when, “someone’s poisoned the Water hole?”

Snark?

Here San Diego: we’ll trade you a guy hitting .216 in Salt Lake, who is about to turn 27, and has spent much of the season on the DL; a $30M reserve OF who is hitting .226 with a .611 OPS in the MLB; and a decent shortstop with chronic hamstring issues.

And in return, we’d like your franchise player, who is in the top three in the league in HRs and walks, and only costs $3M.

Do you have a Twinkie Defense for this fever dream of proposal?

GMJ has a no-trade caluse in his contract.

I doubt he would wave it to be traded to a swell team like the Padres.

I'm sad to say

Gonzales is worth a hell of a lot more than that.

we shouldnt get rid of izzy

better to get rid of aybar

Some retarded, out there trade proposal

Sean O’ Sullivan and Sean Rodriguez for Grady Sizemore! Woot woot!

I think when Grady moves to a competitor, his .235 average will shoot straight up.

Five-Tool OF beast ftw.

That actually would be cool

But he’s an outfielder isn’t he?

True, true

Gosh darn it, I have to reevaluate my trippy deal…

man, i wnat Grady at the Big A badly

that would be a sick outfield.

I agree.

Mainly because I proposed the insane trade idea, but also the fact that GMJ can take some notes from the youngster.

When you can rob homers with your eyes closed and shake up your opponent’s pitcher with an upper deck blast to kick off a ball game, you’re cool in my books.

But one question: Would Sizemore look good in Angels red? Someone photoshop a pic so we can see. :P

Would Grady's Ladies be included in the trade/
Depends. Do you want frightening fangirls camping by the rock pile?
That trade for Holliday and Ellis...

I would much rather stand pat than make that trade.

Izzy, Aybar, Kendrick and Quinlan

And even some farm pitcher for Halladay and Aaron Hill.

Rob can't be tradded


Quato

Quato

Best nickname I’ve heard for Quinnie. So funny

GMJ for Warren Spahn.
The two non-insane proposals both suck IMO.

And the insane ones will never happen obviously. But I’ve always been interested in Heath Bell and he could be available since the Madres suck. Not sure what we would have to give up for him but probably not Wood and he’d help our bullpen tremendously.

I keep hearing Cliff Lee's name being bounced around, what about him?

Something like Wood or SRod, back end SP, and Reckling? could maybe get it done. I know the Indians are looking to unload now.

There's not going to be a monster trade

No matter how much we love SRod or Evans or the other kids with inflated offensive stats from the thin air of SLC, the “5 tool talent” does not exist at the top levels of our farm system to get Halladay, Haren, Lee, Cain, ect.

If we have to trade Weaver to get a SP, it makes absolutely no sense.

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Halos Heaven to post a comment.