SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Halos Heaven

Select Some Upcoming Top 100 Angels

Poll
Best of These Eight Angels
Dave Chalk
8 votes
Bartolo Colon
72 votes
Brendan Donnelly
39 votes
Kelvim Escobar
62 votes
Donnie Moore
57 votes
Johnny Ray
10 votes
Ervin Santana
118 votes
Jered Weaver
10 votes

376 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  12 comments

Comments

Tough choice

They’re all good.

Surprised to see Santana doing so well

Not unhappy. Just surprised.

I agree.

I suppose one good year goes a long way with some people.

or 2

that and bailing Colon out in the ’05 playoffs

exactly. one year as an ace, one other dominant year and one ALDS salvaging.

Okay...

But I’m still voting for Donnie Moore.

As noted below

2 +, actually, and he certainly gets consideration for potential here. I think a lot of people (myself included) anticipate several more years like 2008 for him, considering he’s only 25.

I'm a sucker for those guys who struggle and come back as nails.

It’s like an underdog, except in your miinnnndddd.

he certainly deserves to be somewhere around here on the list

i think this is just a big case of “what have you done for me lately.”

I was a big dan of early 2000's Donnelly
I think it's too early on Santana

he’ll overtake someone like Escobar eventually, but he needs to do a bit more before he’s ahead. One bed-shitting year, one ace year. One ALDS salvaging to Escobar’s ALCS salvaging that was then taken from him when Eddings decided Escobar’s salvage job would require four outs instead of three.

I still will never forget that 2005 ALCS

After winning game 1 and being in great position to potentially win game 2, I was starting to believe during game 2 that the Angels once again were going to go to the World Series. Then somehow AJ P was able to convince the ump that the ball was dropped, make his way to 1st, and we know the rest…..

Looking at that Sox team the baseball Gods were really with them. This was evident not only in the AJ play, but with pitchers like Garland and Conteras who went from below average or mediocre pitchers prior to 2005 to All star caliber during the 2005 regular season then on to dominant, number one aces in the 2005 playoffs and WS.

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Halos Heaven to post a comment.